Dynasty Rookie Rankings 2024, Plus Superflex & Top Players

Here are the full post-draft Dynasty Rookie Rankings for each position as well as the top 60 overall for traditional and Superflex formats.

Find a detailed write-up of the top rookies in our pre-draft rookie rankings:

Click here for our full dynasty rankings!

2024 Dynasty Rookie Rankings:

Click here to go straight to the rankings

Since this is the first year that the rookie ranks are for subscribers only, I wanted to add a bit more context to the rankings here versus solely posting a linear list and walking away.

I also will highlight some of the players I will be targeting and avoiding for clarity.

Last year, I was drafting Jayden Reed and Puka Nacua in a bunch of drafts.

My pre-draft writeups highlighted how much I was into those players, but if you just looked at top-down rankings, that may not have been a slap in the face.

That is a systemic issue with rankings in general, but I do want to provide more clarity on the players I am looking to grab with all of those second-, third- and fourth-round picks out there.

The NFL Draft shaped rookie drafts in a unique way this season.

The NFL had already told us that this was a soft running back class by the way they handled the veteran free agent market, and that followed suit when picks were made.

With Jonathon Brooks being the first running back selected at No. 46 overall, it was the second-lowest pick that the RB1 came off the board in the Super Bowl era.

Brooks does stand to be potential value as a late first-round pick. Dave Canales has already told us that he is going to run the football.

The rub with Brooks is, of course, he is coming off an ACL injury and the non-premier investment.

Any slow start to his career layers increased fragility into his dynasty outlook at a position that does not have a long shelf life.

I prefer to take swings on Brooks in auction formats over being forced to use an isolated draft slot on him, but there are exceptions for extremely thin running back rosters out there.

I have preached patience on not pushing running backs in this class. We are going to be throwing a few calculated darts outside of the first round at the position.

If you have consumed my draft content so far on the site or the podcasts, you already know that I thought that the depth of this wide receiver draft class was largely being oversold because it was being anchored by elite players at the top and then there was a swift drop-off.

If I am not in a position to land one of those elites, I want to attempt to jostle draft position in a way where I am taking multiple swings on these secondary-tier wideouts or just moving those picks for future picks.

We had a plethora of pedestrian production profiles in this class, which I believe created a lot of potential arbitrage in this class.

The draft agreed.

We had all of Brian Thomas Jr, Xavier Worthy, Ricky Pearsall, Xavier Legette, Keon Coleman, Ladd McConkey, and Ja’Lynn Polk selected within 14 picks of each other in the late first and early second rounds.

Both Thomas and Worthy already had a separation from the pack based on high profiles, which were cemented by their draft capital and landing spots.

When I added draft capital to my prospect model, things were not clearer for the rest of that group.

All of Pearsall, McConkey, Legette, Coleman, and Polk ended up within two decimal points of each other in the final score in the model. I have never seen a tighter grouping of prospects, which shows how flat that tier gets in rookie drafts.

You can certainly make the bull case that Coleman, Pearsall, and McConkey get an immediate boost in landing spots over Legette and Polk, but gamers are going to be forced into making hard decisions in the back half of the first round this spring since many will only have one pick in those spots.

One thing I have been harping on all offseason is that if I am holding a mid-to-late first this year, I want to do all that I can to move those picks for future firsts or move down and grab another swing in this class since there was so much potential arbitrage.

If you are a gamer who is not taking one of the quarterbacks or running backs in that area, that is still a plan I fully endorse.

Instead of trying to nail a singular asset from a tightly packed group, I want to either attempt to get multiple cracks at them or just take the cheapest asset and get some added spice later on.

I do want to touch on SuperFlex formats.

One thing you will notice is that I am a touch lower on the secondary quarterbacks in rankings and just wanted to walk through a few angles on why that is and how you can play those spots in rookie drafts.

If you have played in those formats, then you already know that quarterbacks are currency in those leagues.

Any starting quarterback has value because they are finite resources.

If you are desperate to add a quarterback to your roster and are holding a pick in the mid-first, I get it.

But there is a reason that I have the group of J.J. McCarthy, Drake Maye, Bo Nix, and Michael Penix lower than where they will be selected in those formats.

I have written about this numerous times (and recently just had a thread on the old bird app about it).

One thing that SuperFlex and 2QB gamers overvalue is the tier of quarterbacks that have thin odds of threatening to be the QB1 in overall scoring with frequency.

That archetype of quarterback is one of the larger traps in those formats.

By default, I am going to end up drafting more of Nix and Penix at their ADP in those leagues than pushing for McCarthy and Maye, unless I am desperate for a passer.

Then if I am on the clock in the middle of the first, I am trying to sell those picks to a roster that needs quarterbacks firsthand.

With all of that hopefully providing some added context to the ranks and rookie drafts, let’s walk through a few potential targets for the spots we are making picks, starting after Marvin Harrison Jr, Malik Nabers, and Rome Odunze are off the board.

Mid-1st

Xavier Worthy

Late1st/Early 2nd

Ladd McConkey
Jonathon Brooks
Ricky Pearsall
Xavier Legette

Early 2nd

Bo Nix and Michael Penix (SuperFlex only)
Trey Benson
Ja’Lynn Polk

Mid/Late 2nd

Jermaine Burton
Malachi Corley

Early 3rd

Troy Franklin
Ray Davis
Jaylen Wright
Javon Baker

Mid-3rd and Beyond

Kimani Vidal
Ben Sinnott
Tyrone Tracy Jr.
Malik Washington
Isaac Guerendo
Theo Johnson
Erick All

2024 Dynasty Rookie Rankings Table:

Age = Age on 9/1/2024

Player:

Team:

Type:

Rank	Player	Position	Team	RY Age	Type
1	Caleb Williams	QB	CHI	22.8	QB
2	Jayden Daniels	QB	WAS	23.7	QB
3	J.J. McCarthy	QB	MIN	21.6	QB
4	Drake Maye	QB	NE	22.0	QB
5	Bo Nix	QB	DEN	24.5	QB
6	Michael Penix	QB	ATL	24.5	QB
7	Spencer Rattler	QB	NO	23.9	QB
8	Jordan Travis	QB	NYJ	24.3	QB
9	Devin Leary	QB	BAL	25.0	QB
10	Michael Pratt	QB	GB	22.9	QB
11	Joe Milton	QB	NE	24.5	QB
12	Austin Reed	QB	CHI	24.5	QB
13	Sam Hartman	QB	WAS	25.1	QB
14	Kedon Slovis	QB	IND	23.4	QB
1	Jonathon Brooks	RB	CAR	21.1	RB
2	Trey Benson	RB	ARI	22.1	RB
3	Blake Corum	RB	LAR	23.8	RB
4	Ray Davis	RB	BUF	24.8	RB
5	Jaylen Wright	RB	MIA	21.4	RB
6	MarShawn Lloyd	RB	GB	22.7	RB
7	Kimani Vidal	RB	LAC	23.0	RB
8	Tyrone Tracy Jr.	RB	NYG	24.8	RB
9	Audric Estime	RB	DEN	21.0	RB
10	Isaac Guerendo	RB	SF	24.2	RB
11	Bucky Irving	RB	TB	22.0	RB
12	Will Shipley	RB	PHI	22.1	RB
13	Braelon Allen	RB	NYJ	20.6	RB
14	Rasheen Ali	RB	BAL	23.5	RB
15	Dylan Laube	RB	LV	24.7	RB
16	Isaiah Davis	RB	NYJ	22.8	RB
17	Keilan Robinson	RB	JAX	23.1	RB
18	Jase McClellan	RB	ATL	22.2	RB
19	Jawhar Jordan	RB	HOU	25.0	RB
20	Frank Gore Jr.	RB	BUF	22.5	RB
21	Kendall Milton	RB	PHI	22.6	RB
22	Dillon Johnson	RB	TEN	23.2	RB
23	Emani Bailey	RB	KC	22.8	RB
24	Cody Schrader	RB	SF	25.0	RB
25	Jaden Shirden	RB	CAR	22.3	RB
1	Marvin Harrison Jr.	WR	ARI	22.1	WR
2	Malik Nabers	WR	NYG	21.2	WR
3	Rome Odunze	WR	CHI	22.2	WR
4	Brian Thomas Jr.	WR	JAX	21.9	WR
5	Xavier Worthy	WR	KC	21.3	WR
6	Keon Coleman	WR	BUF	21.3	WR
7	Ricky Pearsall	WR	SF	24.0	WR
8	Ladd McConkey	WR	LAC	22.8	WR
9	Xavier Legette	WR	CAR	23.6	WR
10	Ja'Lynn Polk	WR	NE	22.4	WR
11	Adonai Mitchell	WR	IND	22.9	WR
12	Jermaine Burton	WR	CIN	23.2	WR
13	Malachi Corley	WR	NYJ	22.4	WR
14	Troy Franklin	WR	DEN	21.6	WR
15	Roman Wilson	WR	PIT	23.2	WR
16	Jalen McMillan	WR	TB	22.7	WR
17	Devontez Walker	WR	BAL	23.2	WR
18	Javon Baker	WR	NE	22.5	WR
19	Luke McCaffrey	WR	WAS	23.4	WR
20	Malik Washington	WR	MIA	23.7	WR
21	Brenden Rice	WR	LAC	22.5	WR
22	Jacob Cowing	WR	SF	23.6	WR
23	Jamari Thrash	WR	CLE	23.7	WR
24	Anthony Gould	WR	IND	23.4	WR
25	Ryan Flournoy	WR	DAL	24.8	WR
26	Bub Means	WR	NO	23.6	WR
27	Ainias Smith	WR	PHI	23.3	WR
28	Johnny Wilson	WR	PHI	23.4	WR
29	Jha'Quan Jackson	WR	TEN	24.3	WR
30	Casey Washington	WR	ATL	23.5	WR
31	Tejhaun Palmer	WR	ARI	24.0	WR
32	Tahj Washington	WR	MIA	23.3	WR
33	Jordan Whittington	WR	LAR	23.9	WR
34	Cornelius Johnson	WR	LAC	23.8	WR
35	Devaughn Vele	WR	DEN	26.7	WR
36	Jalen Coker	WR	CAR	22.8	WR
37	Isaiah Williams	WR	DET	23.6	WR
38	Xavier Weaver	WR	ARI	23.9	WR
39	Lideatrick Griffin	WR	LV	23.6	WR
40	Marcus Rosemy-Jacksaint	WR	WAS	22.6	WR
1	Brock Bowers	TE	LV	21.7	TE
2	Ben Sinnott	TE	WAS	22.2	TE
3	Theo Johnson	TE	NYG	23.5	TE
4	Ja'Tavion Sanders	TE	CAR	21.4	TE
5	Erick All	TE	CIN	24.0	TE
6	Jared Wiley	TE	KC	23.8	TE
7	Jaheim Bell	TE	NE	23.2	TE
8	Tip Reiman	TE	ARI	23.0	TE
9	Devin Culp	TE	TB	24.6	TE
10	Cade Stover	TE	HOU	24.2	TE
11	AJ Barner	TE	SEA	22.3	TE
12	Tanner McLachlan	TE	CIN	25.5	TE
13	Dallin Holker	TE	NO	24.4	TE
14	Trey Knox	TE	MIN	23.0	TE
15	Jack Westover	TE	SEA	25.2	TE
1	Marvin Harrison Jr.	WR	ARI	22.1	Top-60
2	Malik Nabers	WR	NYG	21.2	Top-60
3	Rome Odunze	WR	CHI	22.2	Top-60
4	Brian Thomas Jr.	WR	JAX	21.9	Top-60
5	Xavier Worthy	WR	KC	21.3	Top-60
6	Brock Bowers	TE	LV	21.7	Top-60
7	Caleb Williams	QB	CHI	22.8	Top-60
8	Jayden Daniels	QB	WAS	23.7	Top-60
9	Keon Coleman	WR	BUF	21.3	Top-60
10	Jonathon Brooks	RB	CAR	21.1	Top-60
11	Ricky Pearsall	WR	SF	24.0	Top-60
12	Ladd McConkey	WR	LAC	22.8	Top-60
13	Xavier Legette	WR	CAR	23.6	Top-60
14	Trey Benson	RB	ARI	22.1	Top-60
15	Ja'Lynn Polk	WR	NE	22.4	Top-60
16	Adonai Mitchell	WR	IND	22.9	Top-60
17	Jermaine Burton	WR	CIN	23.2	Top-60
18	Malachi Corley	WR	NYJ	22.4	Top-60
19	Blake Corum	RB	LAR	23.8	Top-60
20	J.J. McCarthy	QB	MIN	21.6	Top-60
21	Drake Maye	QB	NE	22.0	Top-60
22	Bo Nix	QB	DEN	24.5	Top-60
23	Troy Franklin	WR	DEN	21.6	Top-60
24	Michael Penix	QB	ATL	24.5	Top-60
25	Roman Wilson	WR	PIT	23.2	Top-60
26	Jalen McMillan	WR	TB	22.7	Top-60
27	Ray Davis	RB	BUF	24.8	Top-60
28	Devontez Walker	WR	BAL	23.2	Top-60
29	Javon Baker	WR	NE	22.5	Top-60
30	Jaylen Wright	RB	MIA	21.4	Top-60
31	Ben Sinnott	TE	WAS	22.2	Top-60
32	Luke McCaffrey	WR	WAS	23.4	Top-60
33	MarShawn Lloyd	RB	GB	22.7	Top-60
34	Kimani Vidal	RB	LAC	23.0	Top-60
35	Tyrone Tracy Jr.	RB	NYG	24.8	Top-60
36	Malik Washington	WR	MIA	23.7	Top-60
37	Audric Estime	RB	DEN	21.0	Top-60
38	Isaac Guerendo	RB	SF	24.2	Top-60
39	Theo Johnson	TE	NYG	23.5	Top-60
40	Bucky Irving	RB	TB	22.0	Top-60
41	Ja'Tavion Sanders	TE	CAR	21.4	Top-60
42	Will Shipley	RB	PHI	22.1	Top-60
43	Braelon Allen	RB	NYJ	20.6	Top-60
44	Erick All	TE	CIN	24.0	Top-60
45	Rasheen Ali	RB	BAL	23.5	Top-60
46	Brenden Rice	WR	LAC	22.5	Top-60
47	Jacob Cowing	WR	SF	23.6	Top-60
48	Jamari Thrash	WR	CLE	23.7	Top-60
49	Anthony Gould	WR	IND	23.4	Top-60
50	Ryan Flournoy	WR	DAL	24.8	Top-60
51	Bub Means	WR	NO	23.6	Top-60
52	Ainias Smith	WR	PHI	23.3	Top-60
53	Johnny Wilson	WR	PHI	23.4	Top-60
54	Dylan Laube	RB	LV	24.7	Top-60
55	Jha'Quan Jackson	WR	TEN	24.3	Top-60
56	Isaiah Davis	RB	NYJ	22.8	Top-60
57	Keilan Robinson	RB	JAX	23.1	Top-60
58	Jase McClellan	RB	ATL	22.2	Top-60
59	Casey Washington	WR	ATL	23.5	Top-60
60	Tejhaun Palmer	WR	ARI	24.0	Top-60
1	Caleb Williams	QB	CHI	22.8	SuperFLEX
2	Marvin Harrison Jr.	WR	ARI	22.1	SuperFLEX
3	Jayden Daniels	QB	WAS	23.7	SuperFLEX
4	Malik Nabers	WR	NYG	21.2	SuperFLEX
5	Rome Odunze	WR	CHI	22.2	SuperFLEX
6	Brian Thomas Jr.	WR	JAX	21.9	SuperFLEX
7	Xavier Worthy	WR	KC	21.3	SuperFLEX
8	Brock Bowers	TE	LV	21.7	SuperFLEX
9	J.J. McCarthy	QB	MIN	21.6	SuperFLEX
10	Drake Maye	QB	NE	22.0	SuperFLEX
11	Bo Nix	QB	DEN	24.5	SuperFLEX
12	Keon Coleman	WR	BUF	21.3	SuperFLEX
13	Jonathon Brooks	RB	CAR	21.1	SuperFLEX
14	Michael Penix	QB	ATL	24.5	SuperFLEX
15	Ricky Pearsall	WR	SF	24.0	SuperFLEX
16	Ladd McConkey	WR	LAC	22.8	SuperFLEX
17	Xavier Legette	WR	CAR	23.6	SuperFLEX
18	Trey Benson	RB	ARI	22.1	SuperFLEX
19	Ja'Lynn Polk	WR	NE	22.4	SuperFLEX
20	Adonai Mitchell	WR	IND	22.9	SuperFLEX
21	Jermaine Burton	WR	CIN	23.2	SuperFLEX
22	Malachi Corley	WR	NYJ	22.4	SuperFLEX
23	Troy Franklin	WR	DEN	21.6	SuperFLEX
24	Blake Corum	RB	LAR	23.8	SuperFLEX
25	Roman Wilson	WR	PIT	23.2	SuperFLEX
26	Jalen McMillan	WR	TB	22.7	SuperFLEX
27	Ray Davis	RB	BUF	24.8	SuperFLEX
28	Devontez Walker	WR	BAL	23.2	SuperFLEX
29	Javon Baker	WR	NE	22.5	SuperFLEX
30	Jaylen Wright	RB	MIA	21.4	SuperFLEX
31	Ben Sinnott	TE	WAS	22.2	SuperFLEX
32	Luke McCaffrey	WR	WAS	23.4	SuperFLEX
33	MarShawn Lloyd	RB	GB	22.7	SuperFLEX
34	Kimani Vidal	RB	LAC	23.0	SuperFLEX
35	Tyrone Tracy Jr.	RB	NYG	24.8	SuperFLEX
36	Malik Washington	WR	MIA	23.7	SuperFLEX
37	Audric Estime	RB	DEN	21.0	SuperFLEX
38	Isaac Guerendo	RB	SF	24.2	SuperFLEX
39	Theo Johnson	TE	NYG	23.5	SuperFLEX
40	Bucky Irving	RB	TB	22.0	SuperFLEX
41	Ja'Tavion Sanders	TE	CAR	21.4	SuperFLEX
42	Will Shipley	RB	PHI	22.1	SuperFLEX
43	Braelon Allen	RB	NYJ	20.6	SuperFLEX
44	Erick All	TE	CIN	24.0	SuperFLEX
45	Spencer Rattler	QB	NO	23.9	SuperFLEX
46	Rasheen Ali	RB	BAL	23.5	SuperFLEX
47	Jordan Travis	QB	NYJ	24.3	SuperFLEX
48	Brenden Rice	WR	LAC	22.5	SuperFLEX
49	Jacob Cowing	WR	SF	23.6	SuperFLEX
50	Jamari Thrash	WR	CLE	23.7	SuperFLEX
51	Anthony Gould	WR	IND	23.4	SuperFLEX
52	Ryan Flournoy	WR	DAL	24.8	SuperFLEX
53	Bub Means	WR	NO	23.6	SuperFLEX
54	Ainias Smith	WR	PHI	23.3	SuperFLEX
55	Johnny Wilson	WR	PHI	23.4	SuperFLEX
56	Dylan Laube	RB	LV	24.7	SuperFLEX
57	Isaiah Davis	RB	NYJ	22.8	SuperFLEX
58	Keilan Robinson	RB	JAX	23.1	SuperFLEX
59	Jha'Quan Jackson	WR	TEN	24.3	SuperFLEX
60	Jase McClellan	RB	ATL	22.2	SuperFLEX
	Player		Team		Type