2026 NFL Receiving Prop Bets: Best Unders to Target

2026 NFL Unders: Best Receiver Prop Bets

• Jaxon Smith-Njigba — Under 1324.5 Receiving Yards (-110)
• Courtland Sutton — Under 59.5 Receptions (-125)

Fantasy football projections, like those done by Rich Hribar, can be a guide to help identify overvalued or undervalued players in the current betting markets.

Using our projections, I will identify a couple of players at each position who we are lower on than the current market.

Get More Player & Team Picks in Warren Sharp's Futures Package

Warren Sharp's Futures Package has compiled a 98-55 (64%) record on non-longshot props over the last seven years.

A $100 bettor is up $7,944 following Warren's futures since this package was created.

Click here to learn more about our 2026 Futures Package!

Jaxon Smith-Njigba 2026 Over/Under Prediction

Jaxon Smith-Njigba is coming off a season in which he had 35.8% of the Seahawks' targets and 50% of the team’s air yards

He also led the league in receiving yards.

It may seem difficult to bet the under on a player ascending to superstar status, but those numbers will be nearly impossible to repeat.

The market is pricing in another elite season, and betting the under is essentially betting that his 2025 season represents the high-end of his range rather than the beginning of a new top-two receiver in the league baseline.

Five receivers exceeded 1,300 receiving yards last season, and only two the season prior.

The high total is extremely difficult to reach and requires good fortune as well as skill.

Smith-Njigba's 2025 production was extraordinary, but producing at that level is the biggest reason to bet the under.

The third-year breakout shouldn’t surprise many since Smith-Njigba was the first receiver off the board in the 2023 NFL Draft, but he more than doubled his career high in yards per route.

Klint Kubiak pulled all the right levers in his first year with the Seahawks, as Smith-Njigba recorded 575 yards on his 14 receptions that traveled more than 20 air yards (41.1 yards per reception).

That type of success on deep passes will be difficult to replicate.

Smith-Njigba dominated Seattle's target distribution.

He was fifth in targets despite the Seahawks finishing the season 29th in pass attempts.

In his first two seasons, Smith-Njigba was targeted on 20.9% of his routes.

That jumped to 33.5% last season.

As well as target regression, efficiency regression could be coming.

He averaged 15.1 yards per reception in 2025, up from 11.3 yards per reception in 2024 and 10.0 yards per reception in his rookie season.

Target competition should increase.

The Seahawks re-signed Rashid Shaheed to a lucrative deal in the offseason, signalling the likelihood of an increasing role for the speedy wide receiver who joined the team at the trade deadline.

What made Smith-Njigba’s 2025 season so incredible was the consistency with which he performed.

He eclipsed 70 or more receiving yards in 16 games.

That type of consistency will be difficult to replicate considering teams will be more focused on shutting down the best passing option for the Seahawks.

With two weeks to prepare, the Patriots forced the Seahawks to use ancillary receivers, limiting Smith-Njigba to 4 receptions and 27 yards in the Super Bowl.

It is likely that teams will copy this blueprint, forcing the Seahawks to use other receiving options more than in the 2025 season.

A new offensive environment adds uncertainty.

Seattle is also entering 2026 with their third different offensive coordinator in the three seasons under Mike Macdonald.

Although new offensive coordinator Brian Fleury comes from the same coaching tree as Kubiak, he joins the Seahawks as a first-time play-caller, a difficult task given the fact that the head coach is a defensive guru.

Despite winning a Super Bowl, Sam Darnold isn’t a lock as one of the league’s best passers.

In fact, he had 10 interceptions in his opening 10 games as a Seahawk and isn’t exempt from seeing ghosts.

Last year's Super Bowl victory has provided a bit of market overconfidence in an offense with several ranges of outcomes.

The under has several paths to victory: target regression, increased competition from Shaheed, Tory Horton, AJ Barner, and Elijah Arroyo, regression in yards per reception, changes in Seattle's offensive distribution, or simply missing a game or two.

A successful season doesn't have to assume Smith-Njigba falls back to his rookie-season production.

The combination of slightly fewer targets and slightly lower yards per target can have a significant effect over a full season.

He could catch 100-plus passes, remain one of the league's most productive receivers, and still finish below 1,325 yards.

This bet is simply a bet against the unsustainable success of last season and the market’s potential overconfidence in the wide receiver and Seahawks offense after one incredible season.

Jaxon Smith-Njigba Prop Bet Recommendation

• Under 1324.5 Receiving Yards (-110)

Courtland Sutton 2026 Over/Under Prediction

Courtland Sutton is coming off back-to-back 1,000-yard seasons with Bo Nix and Sean Payton in Denver, but his production could take a step back this season.

Sutton turns 31-years-old in October, and there are some red flags indicating a drop in production could occur.

As sports science has progressed, the age cliff in which wide receivers’ drop-off has not been as prominent as a decade ago.

However, the outside-clasher profiles like Sutton have struggled into their thirties more than the versatile receivers who move all over the field.

Over his career, Sutton has played 85.1% of his snaps outside, and the Broncos have several options to play in the slot.

The biggest reason to fade Sutton this season is the aggressive addition of Jaylen Waddle, whom the Broncos traded a first-round, third-round, and fourth-round pick to acquire.

There were signals last season that Sutton’s role in the offense wasn’t as secure as previous years.

In Rich Hribar’s wide receiver tiers, he noted that from Week 2 to Week 11, Troy Franklin out-targeted Sutton (75 to 65) and even out-targeted him in the end zone (9 to 5) over that period.

Franklin was wildly inefficient, and the Broncos were forced to lean on Sutton down the stretch.

That led to double-digit targets in four consecutive games from Week 14 to Week 17.

The early-season Franklin usage and the steep price paid for Waddle are concerning for Sutton’s high-volume usage in this offense.

Payton has also talked favorably about second-year wide receiver Pat Bryant, who had increased usage down the stretch of his rookie year.

Marvin Mims enters his fourth season with the Broncos, and his best game of the season was in the playoffs before Nix’s injury.

Payton has historically rotated wide receivers, which has not affected Sutton's usage, but this is the deepest wide receiver depth chart since Payton arrived.

Waddle is an excellent fit for this Bronco offense, which leans on screens, go-routes, and crossers.

His addition is a real concern for Sutton's targets.

The 2025 Broncos were a pass-heavy offense, which is partially because of an injury to J.K. Dobbins while rookie running back RJ Harvey struggled with down-to-down rushing efficiency.

Sutton was fourth in the league with 616 routes, which is a difficult number to reproduce as it requires optimal health and one of the league's highest pass rates.

Dobbins returns to the lineup, and the addition of Jonah Coleman provides multiple options to increase the rush rate behind one of the league’s best offensive lines.

The 59.5 reception number for Sutton requires him to maintain a level of opportunity that is difficult to project given the changes to the offense around him.

It is possible that Sutton is a boom-or-bust deep threat, similar to the way Alec Pierce was utilized in Indianapolis last season.

For that reason, the season-long reception under is more favorable than the yardage total.

Waddle could open some deep passing success, and Sutton’s yards per catch could rise.

The Sharp Football Projections have Sutton at 65 receptions, a 9-reception decrease from last season.

That said, a larger drop would not be shocking even if Sutton remains healthy.

If Waddle commands a significant target share and Franklin, Bryant, Mims, and Denver's tight ends all receive meaningful opportunities, Sutton's path to another 100-target season becomes much more difficult to project, making Sutton a solid reception total under bet.

Sutton’s reception total under provides multiple opportunities.

It is not unreasonable to think his role in the offense decreases and he stays under the total even if he plays all 17 games.

Any injury time makes it unlikely that he reaches 60 receptions.

Courtland Sutton Prop Bet Recommendation

• Under 59.5 Receptions (-125)